REVIEW: The Wizard of Oz – Harrogate Phoenix Players

Everybody knows and loves the classic tale of Dorothy Gale, even more so now that Wicked has reignited the world’s fascination with the land of Oz. So, full credit to Harrogate Phoenix Players for stepping up to the challenge of staging such an iconic show right in the midst of Oz-mania.

The undeniable star of the show is Dorothy herself, played by Hannah Thomson. With a background in Opera North Youth Chorus, it’s no surprise that she delivers stunning vocals throughout. Her heartfelt performance ensures that Somewhere Over the Rainbow remains a show-stopping moment rather than just a box-ticking obligation.

Dorothy is, of course, joined by her trio of faithful friends: Lion (Daniel Martin), Tin Man (James Wilstrop), and Scarecrow (Clive Kirkham). However, due to an unfortunate accident that left Clive with broken limbs (not ideal when your whole character is based on movement), Rob Hastings stepped in as understudy with less than two weeks’ notice. Given the circumstances, Hastings has done a phenomenal job in what is, let’s face it, a huge role to cover. Who you’ll see on the night? Well, you’ll have to buy a ticket to find out. The characters are played well with each actor finding their own take on the well-known roles without straying too far from what audiences expect. Their camaraderie with Dorothy is engaging, and their journey down the Yellow Brick Road is full of fun moments.

Director and choreographer Angela Edwards ensures that the ensemble plays a vital role, with poppies, Winkie Guards, Emerald City citizens, and my personal favourite – the singing and dancing Land Girl Apple Trees – all getting their moment to shine. And then there were… the Abominable Snowmen. Don’t ask. A pop culture joke that, like me, anyone born post-1990 probably won’t get.

Musical Director James Rodgers brings out strong vocals across the whole company, including the munchkins played by local children, who add bundles of energy and charm to the munchkins scenes and mischievousness to the Jitterbug featuring the entire cast.

Now, I should mention that I attended the technical rehearsal, so a few minor pacing, set, and lighting hiccups can be forgiven – that’s what tech runs are for, after all. What’s important is that the costumes were vibrant, unique, and fully embraced the magic of Oz.

No production of The Wizard of Oz would be complete without its two contrasting witches. Suzannah Todd’s Glinda floats around with an elfish, hippy vibe – imagine Galadriel from The Lord of the Rings, but on something a little stronger than lembas bread. In stark contrast, Tracey Rea’s Wicked Witch of the West delivers a deliciously menacing performance, complete with a 10/10 evil cackle.

The Wizard himself, played by Richard Naylor, adds a touch of charm and even a little sleight-of-hand magic, proving that sometimes the man behind the curtain is worth paying attention to.

A special mention must go to the show’s most adorable cast member, Olive the dog, playing Toto. Sharing the role was a beautifully crafted puppet by Eleanor Kitchen, expertly puppeteered by Katie Gray, ensuring that even when Olive wasn’t on stage, Toto remained a presence.

The Wizard of Oz has always “held space” (diehard Wicked fans should get that reference) in my heart. Having played Scarecrow a good ten years ago, and with a bucket list that still includes Tin Man, Lion, and maybe even the Wicked Witch, I was excited to revisit this classic – and I’m glad I did.

Congratulations to the Harrogate Phoenix Players for a solid and entertaining production. With only a few tickets left for Wednesday and Thursday’s performances, don’t miss your chance to follow the yellow brick road one more time.